Showing posts with label video. Show all posts
Showing posts with label video. Show all posts

Sunday, November 20, 2011

BECAUSE THE PROPER RESPONSE TO "JUMP" IS "HOW HIGH" - The UC Davis Edition

Photographer Lois Greenfield writes on her website
I can’t depict the moments before or after the camera’s click, but I invite the viewer’s consideration of that question.
Lois reminded me recently as we were talking about landscape and gardens and Central Park, that because an artist may be trying to improve nature, what may look natural may be entirely contrived. And yet (this was a subtext to what she was saying, I think), in the photograph, even the photoshopped photograph, there is always, at some level, the image.  Which is and carries its own truth.
Jean Luc Goddard once said that 
Film is truth at 24 frames a second.
Which makes something of the same point.
* * * * *
Come with me now to the campus of the University of California at Davis.  And meet Lieutenant John Pike.
There's the still at the center of the changing world.

And there's the video.

And there's the longer video.

To my eyes, the still is the most horrifying.  As they say on the internet, your mileage may vary.
* * * * *
When Reginald Brooks was executed in Ohio last Tuesday despite his mental illness and the state's almost 30 year effort to conceal just how crazy he really was, he spoke no last words.
But strapped to the table (it's not really a gurney), and as the murderers execution team members pushed the plungers that sent the pentobarbital that would kill him through the IV lines, he gave them the finger.
With both hands.
Had he been at Davis, they might have stopped the killing long enough to bring out the pepper spray.

Tuesday, July 26, 2011

Truth. Fairness. Transparency

I've been meaning for a few days now to write about the murder of Andrew Grant DeYoung by the State of Georgia last week.  
I don't know a thing about the crime of which he was convicted.  I don't know anything about him.  I had no plan to write about prosecutorial misconduct, competence of counsel, AEDPA, judicial integrity, any of that stuff.  What I intended to write about is the only thing of any consequence I know about his case.
They made a video of the execution.
Erica Goode in the New York Times:
The camera recorded his last words — “I’m sorry for everyone I’ve hurt” — and his eyes blinking as the drugs took effect. It registered his last breaths and the time of his death: 8:04 p.m.
For decades in the United States, what goes on inside the execution chamber has been largely shrouded from public view, glimpsed only through the accounts of journalists and other witnesses.
But the video recording of Mr. DeYoung’s death, the first since 1992, has once again raised the possibility that executions might be made available for all to see. In the process, it has reignited a widespread debate about how bright a light to shine on one of the most secretive corners of the criminal justice system.
It's no secret that we've turned executions from public spectacle - town square at high noon, thousands watching - into private one.  Just as it's no secret that we've done all we can to sanitize the murders.  We give the pretense of medicalization.  We eschew blood.  We favor the pretense of dignity and decorum.
And the video of Mr. DeYoung's killing?  It's to be kept under seal, by the court, with the intention that nobody will ever see it.
After Mr. DeYoung’s execution, the video was sealed and sent to a judge’s chambers for safekeeping, and Mr. Kammer [DeYoung's lawyer who convinced a judge to allow the recording], for one, said he hoped it stayed hidden. “It’s a horrible thing that Andrew DeYoung had to go through, and it’s not for the public to see that,” he said.
But Douglas Berman, a professor of law at Ohio State University who commented on the issue on his blog, Sentencing and Law Policy, said, “I think it would be foolish for anybody who is authorizing or supervising the videotaping of executions to assume that it will always remain sealed and unseen.” Mr. Berman added, “Somewhere, somehow, at some point, this will become publicly accessible.”
Of course, Doug is right.  There's almost no chance that the video will forever remain secret.  Not in this YouTube world.  
Frankly, it shouldn't.  Not because there's any lesson to it.  By all accounts, DeYoung's murder looked entirely peaceful and calm, pleasant even.  The sort of death we might all like to have, though perhaps on our timetable rather than on the government's.
No, the video should be made public because there's little that the government can do to people that's more final.  We should, as I've said repeatedly here, admit what we're doing.  
Goode quotes Debby Denno, a professor at Fordham Law.
“Most of what we do in the criminal justice system in terms of punishment is something that is allegedly open to the public,” Ms. Denno said, “and this is the ultimate form of our process.” 
So it is.  And as I've said repeatedly here, if we're going to be in the business of killing people, if we think it's that important, we should be open and transparent about it.
That's roughly what I've been meaning to write for a few days now.  Somehow though, I never quite got around to it.  Then Nafissatou Diallo, the woman who claimed to have been sexually assaulted by Dominique Strauss-Kahn, held a press conference.  I had not intention of writing about that.  I still don't.
She's a documented liar who apparently hopes to profit off her allegations.  That doesn't make them true.  It also doesn't make them false.  It does make her a lousy witness and the legal case against him filled with more holes than a good emmentaler.  But really, I don't care.  
So why do I mention it?  Because of Clyde Haberman's City Room blog post, Lifting the Veil of Anonymity in Sex Assault Cases, in the on-line Times.  Haberman uses Diallo's outing of herself to talk about the how the US media mostly conceal the names of those women who claim to have been sexually assaulted.
Until this latest turn, major American news organizations had guarded her identity. Even though her name and picture appeared weeks ago in foreign media outlets, notably in France, American newspapers and television stations abided by a longstanding policy of not identifying those who say they have been sexually assaulted. That anonymity is not routinely offered victims of other crimes.
Haberman's discussion is really about whether the alleged victims of sexual assault - and women in general - benefit from the media's commitment to keep their identity secret.  In point of fact, though, that's absolutely the wrong question.  The right question is whether the alleged perpetrators of sexual assault are treated unfairly by what is really the media's presumption that any allegation of sexual misconduct must be true.  And must be treated as true from the moment it is made until forever, even if it turns out to be demonstrably false.
See, here's the thing.
The identity of the accused is a public record and often a media sensation.
  • Kobe Bryant was accused.
  • Ben Roethlisberger was accused.
  • The Central Park five were accused.
  • The Duke lacross players were accused.
  • Congressman whoever was accused.
  • Some former high school guidance counselor was accused.
  • The guy down the street was accused.
They are all named.  Pictures in the paper.  Details of the accusation laid bare (sorry).  All as described by the "victim" whose identity is kept secret because she (almost always a she) has been harmed enough.  And because it's so important that accusations be made.
And we know she's a victim.  And we know she's been harmed enough.  Because he (almost always a he) did it, whatever exactly it was.  And we know he did it because she said so.  And nobody ever falsely accuses anyone of any sort of misconduct.
Oh, wait.  People do just that.
And then there's a new bunch of identified victims.  Who continue to suffer the obloquy of accusation.  Who continue to be treated as guilty.  They're the innocent accused.  But the dishonest accuser?  She (mostly she) continues to have the protection of anonymity because it's just so damned important that she feel safe to come forward and accuse someone innocent.
We in the criminal defense business know that this is all about the presumption of guilt.  And is another of the great lies in our business.
Which brings me to another bit of news.
Findings from a newly released study refute the claim that more than 100,000 of the nation’s registered sex offenders are missing and unaccounted for – a figure that has commonly appeared in statements from government officials, Congressional legislation and dozens of media accounts since 2003.  

The release of these findings coincides with the approaching July 27 deadline for states to comply with federal sex offender registration requirements set forth in the 2006 Adam Walsh Child Protection and Safety Act. As of July 18, only eight states have been deemed to have substantially implemented these requirements, and many have called for Congress to revisit key provisions in the law. The “100,000 missing” figure was repeatedly cited in the debates leading to the law’s passage and in its subsequent re-authorization hearings earlier this year.
Let's just focus on that for a moment.  Congress passes the Adam Walsh Act and pressures states to pass their own versions in order to help everyone keep track of those convicted of sex offenses.  Because 100,000 registered sex offenders can't be found, we need a law to ensure that more sex offenders will be required to register.  OK, that makes no sense.
But then our sex offender registration and notification laws have never made much sense.  They're about the pretense of good sense.  If we know that the guy down the street is a registered sex offender, we can keep the kiddies away from him.  You know, let them hang out with the parish priest.  (Ooops.)  Or Uncle Festus.  (Double ooops.)
And the guy down the street?  The one who urinated in public?  The one who had sex with his girlfriend when he was 19 and she was 15 and now they've been married for 25 years and have kids but can't live near a school or day care center or even a DQ.  And he can't get a job because he's a kiddie rapist for gods sake.  (Public urination being a well-known attribute of all kiddie rapists and of nobody else.) And he's the one we're watching out for?
But even then, and even if you think it's all about somehow tracking down that 100,000 (mostly) guys.  It turns out that it's a made up number with no relationship to reality.  But of course we don't care.
I was talking to a reporter yesterday about the Ohio Supreme Court's latest opinion finding part of our version of the Adam Walsh Act unconstitutional.  I told him about how the law doesn't achieve its end.  How it even makes things worse.  And along the way I offered this truth, which I'm nowhere near the first to observe.
It's always a mistake when they name a law after a child.
That's one truth.  Here's another.  Secrecy breeds dishonesty.  And here's yet another.  Getting it right matters.
Truth.  Fairness.  Transparency.
Which is what I called this post.

Tuesday, August 4, 2009

Roll the tape

You know the old saw about how a picture is worth a thousand words. Well, this dramatic thing started happening a couple of decades ago.

People got video cameras and began taping stuff happening around them. The next thing you know, there's Rodney King getting the shit beaten out of him by the Los Angeles police right there on your television.

Fast forward, if you'll excuse the expression, a couple of years and video cameras started showing up in police stations. So you saw the police sexually assaulting a young woman in the Elkhart police station.

And with cameras in police cars, especially with the audio, just last week you might have seen the police planting drugs on someone and having the dog attack him. You might, also, have seen police in Florida planning to pin a DUI on a woman for an accident they caused.

And because of cameras in convenience stores attached to gas stations, we get to see Philadelphia police assaulting and then arresting a woman after the son of one of the officers rear-ended her car.

None of this is new. What's new is just how much of it there is. And that we get to see it for ourselves.

And just how dumb the cops are to do all this stuff while the tape is rolling. Or maybe they're not so dumb. Maybe it's an ingrained part of their culture, of the thin blue line, to accept that these things happen and to recognize that there aren't likely to be repercussions.

The truth is that police brutality, even outright criminality, is rarely punished with more than a slap on the wrist, if that. That woman who was beaten and arrested in the gas station. Officers asked the station owner to destroy the tape. He didn't. Internal affairs concluded they did nothing wrong.

Huh?

Juries believe what police say on the witness stand even when it's a lie. So do judges, who really do know better. It's called "testilying," and however much we all disapprove, the system tolerates at least some degree of it.

Years ago, I had a drug case. Two cars were driving on the Ohio Turnpike. It was a January afternoon. A highway patrol trooper, who testified that she was driving west at 65 miles per hour in the far right lane, noticed that the drivers of two cars going east, in the far lanes on their side of the road, also going about 65 miles an hour, had similar facial features. Yes, that's right. Across four lanes of traffic, a grass medial strip that was significantly wider than the length of a police car. Windows closed. Similar facial features.

Try it yourself next time you're on the highway. Bet you can't do it.

Anyway, she got suspicious. She found an excuse to stop one of the cars and radioed for another trooper to stop the other. His excuse for stopping the car: It was following too closely a semi that was driving faster than the car. Wait, isn't there something about the laws of physics here?

The judge believed the troopers. Or said she did.

Of course, there wasn't any video.
____________

Note: I've been saving these videos for a couple of weeks and can't frankly, tell you where I found most of them. But my sources include: Simple Justice, Jonathan Turley, Crime and Federalism, and Criminal Defense. If I forgot someone, or lost track, I apologize.